The (REAL) Problem With Social Media Marketing » Probable Dollar

and the threats they pose to your business and livelihood

The Problem With Social Media Marketing
(and why you should still use it)

Imagine this! You start a business that caters to people’s interest in haunted houses and Halloween.

Your online content is engaging and your operations are thriving. All due, in part, to your social media savvy and hard work.

You’ve dedicated years to building relationships with your customers. You’re on Facebook and have grown a respectable following on the platform.

It seems like magic every time you post. Engagement and traffic to your page is through the roof.

You’re doing social media right! Congratulations.

Fast forward a few years and you now have, what you consider, a massive following.

Then you start asking yourself…

Why is my social media marketing not working?

But something doesn’t seem right. When you post you notice that your engagement is declining each month.

The reach is going down as well. Why aren’t your followers seeing your content or engaging with it?

Scratching your head.

You explore post frequency, viral content, product giveaways, all with little success.

Then the notification pops up “Reach your 600K followers for only $100”.

Something clicks

You realize, Facebook wants you to pay for the screen time of your content

Even for the people that have subscribed to your content.

Pay to Play is Nothing New to Advertisers. This is no different. You have to up your organic game AND your paid advertising game. That’s the new normal. It could be worse, though.

A pay to play model is nothing new to advertisers

What is new is the arbitrary control over your investment

When a business invests years into a platform they need to consider the future of that platform

How that platform will monetize, and how they will control growing pains

It is clear that Facebook’s goal is to grow revenue for shareholders through its ad network

That’s capitalism.

This is how it turns bad…


In real life, there is a haunted house facebook page with over 600K subscribers.

Here is where the trouble comes in.

Business owners want to be in control of their business

(crazy, right?)

If you’re investing in social without an external endgame, you are NOT in control.

I’ll get to the external end game in a moment.

First, the inspiration for this Op-ed.

It came as I was scrolling through my personal Instagram account.

Looking for Halloween stuff for my son and me…

I came across this post and description:

A bit of a victim tone, but at the end of the day, they are being victimized, by Facebook and

by THEIR own lack of planning.

This is the arbitrary control I was speaking of…

and the problem with not having an external end game.

They invested 5 years of time, grew to over 600K subscribers – and in one day that was all reduced to ZERO. They have nothing to show for what they’ve done.

Had they come into social media with an ownership mindset this would not have been as severe.

Likely, Facebook’s decision would not have harmed them in such a drastic way.

Since Facebook decided their niche was “Fake News”, they’re now OFF the platform.

In reality, this page is paying for Facebook’s fake news fiasco.

Having to incur the wrath of their “too late” damage control.

What matters is what you CHOOSE to give up when you focus on a “Social First” strategy with no external end game.

You give up control over the future of your business and hand it to a “Too Big To Care” platform.

Your 600K followers seem like a lot to you.

To Facebook with it’s 1 Billion + users…

it is a pebble of sand in a vast ocean.

The External Endgame: Making Your Following Your OWN.

The goal for EVERY business should be to grow its own internal contact list and customer database.

Using Facebook as your end all be all is a recipe for disaster like we’ve seen above.

So how could this Haunted House group have mitigated their disaster?

By creating a strong “off social presence”.

As in a business website that focuses on collecting emails!

This is a key first (or very early) step every business needs to take.

Start hoarding those emails now and forever.

Engage with your audience by giving them what they want.

In this case…

You own the relationship.

It is up to you and your customers if they read or see your content, or even whether they continue to subscribe.

It will be a decision (on a more intimate level) between your customers and you.

The only real middleman is the SPAM filter.

The rest is on you.

Had they (the Halloween page) spent the time driving traffic to a website with lead magnets

and useful content they would…

a) Be more successful and

b) not be in the position they are in now, having to choose between starting over or closing shop.

What a blow for an entrepreneur!

Where’s my Audience?

Going back to the issue of reach.

This is a very real problem.

It doesn’t matter if you have 1,000 followers or 500,000.

Facebook is reducing the reach of Page posts.

Money. Next question.

How much have they reduced it?

That is hard to say.

I did recently come across this medium post.

Detailing the Chicago Tribune’s problems with Facebook reach.

The rise in posts that are getting less than 10,000 reach shows this is a real issue for businesses.

The current organic, workaround for this is creating groups with a strong following.

Group posts, reach their audience at much higher percentages than public posts.

For how long is anyone’s guess…

The Pay to Play Model is Here to Stay (no significant strategy or content changed in this time on the part of the Chicago Tribune)

What You Can Do About It!

To avoid or reduce the impact this has on your business follow these 3 strategies. You can start implementing them now.

    Collect emails. Whether on your site, facebook lead ads, or through a hosted landing page. Start collecting and growing your list. “Get good” at email marketing. The ROI has been the best, on a general level, for over a decade. No sign of changing there.
    Post Less – Let those posts ride. Don’t cannibalize your reach by over posting.
    Post More (great content that is). Make your content epic! Figure out what your customers want and give it to them. Spend the time you used to spend making 5 posts and dedicate it to making one GREAT post. (then promote it of course, and make sure it has a CTA to your site)

Why should you continue using Facebook? Social Media Marketing?

You already know why.

It allows you to find and connect with people in your niche and industry.

It is an amazing tool, the likes of which, advertisers have never had at their fingertips until now.

I want to sell a house, Facebook target people that have the behavior “likely to move” and live in these geographic areas.

Find people that will shop at my hardware store.

In Ad Manager, I target people that live in your business area.

Have an interest in small/local business, enjoy DIY projects and watch a lot of HGTV.

I am oversimplifying slight, but you get the point…

It is an amazing tool!

The keyword here is “tool”.

Use it that way and you’ll be in a good position.

Use it as a business and you’re giving away your control to a platform.

It is something we should be giving thought to for your next major marketing strategy.

Groups are another great opportunity for building a strong community and brand presence.

Facebook groups are exploding.

I’ve been a part of several, including lifetime tech deals, that gained 1,000’s of organic followers daily.

There are many opportunities.

Who controls the content and delivery.

The platform.

The customers.

The answer, if you’re a business owner, should be you. Do that through list and community building.

By Robert McMillin

Digital Marketer


Article by channel:

Read more articles tagged: Social Media